With more shea, the lotion will be solid w/out me having to use the fridge. Now the weather is cooling down and it has harden and the minerals is rough on the lips on first application, and softer on second or third application, and the balm feels dry on application. What can I substitute coconut oil with in a shaving cream recipe thats non-comedogenic? I am in the process of making my own face serum and body oil. Heres how to walk yourself through that. Borage seed oil is POSSIBLY SAFE when taken by mouth or applied to the skin appropriately.. Borage seed oil is LIKELY UNSAFE when products containing a dangerous chemicals called pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs) are taken by mouth. Geranium (Pelargonium graveolens) essential oil is an acceptable substitute for rose oil. All in all, I would recommend working with these oils individually and getting to know them personallytheres really no substitute for that, especially when were talking about your skin and your body. I look forward to your other material! What is a good alternative? Shea butter is not a thing Id put in an anti-acne creamthats a bit like asking what you could add to spinach to make a cake. Hello Marie! Check out my different wax quick guides to learn how different waxes perform in comparison to beeswax . I was reading through your post and kind of thought that maybe cocoa butter would be better but I just wanted to double-check. Hey Cindy! Namely 7-keto You can definitely use slower to absorb, thicker oils and butters (avocado, shea), but I would also recommend toying with your beeswax percentage . I tried it again but with less Shea butter and a little more wax and it was still very oily. Thanks so much for all your helpful, well-written posts. Dosing. Thanks, Salome! GLA is also found in borage oil and black currant oil. Im not a beekeeper or chef so my info might not be accurate however these seems like the most valid subs. In terms of texture, coconut oil is smooth and oily; shea butter is thick, tacky, and sticky. The leaves have a faint smell of cucumber. What did I do wrong? {In A lip gloss recipe} GLA typically comprises about 24% of the oil. I found some recipes for it online and they were just shredded, dried coconut run through a blender, like peanut butter. Chances are the neem oil is the magic ingredient in that eczema salve; if you want to ditch it I would choose a different recipe entirely , I have been making tinted lip balm in a pushup tube with virgin coconut oil (22%), unrefined shea butter (23%), grapeseed oil (32%), candelilla wax (15%) and natural mineral (9%). Extracted from the seeds of the plant, this is my choice for all things hormonal; premenstrual, perimenopausal, menopausal, post-menopausal and puberty. How can I make sure its a reliable substitute? can i use it instead of z camellia seed oil? I know that I am coming into the conversation late, but I am very allergic to tree nuts so I dont use their oils. Bummer on the psoriasis My first suggestion would be shea butter, which Ive found to be fantastic for eczema. You do you. Mango and cupuacu butters would be my top recommendations as a replacement for shea butter . Can I add Shea Butter on my sugar, coconut oil, almond oil to make a more creamy scrub? I dont know if I am making a good decision removing olive and sweet almond oil, or whether I should keep them in the mix along with all the others. Borage Oil is a good choice for: Sensitive Skin: If you are susceptible to redness, inflammation or even rosacea - borage oil helps to keep your skin soothed and calm. A 2014 study comparing borage oil, fish oil, and the combination of both found that taking 1.8 grams of borage oil or 2.1 grams of fish oil per day (or both) helped reduce rheumatoid arthritis (RA . ), and then getting thrown away down the drain. Is there a substitute that can be used in stead? Borage oil has been shown to be effective at helping people maintain significant weight loss. Borage oil and fish oil have been added to the formula to provide 0.9 grams of gamma linolenic acid, 0.1 grams of eicosapentaenoic acid, and 0.5 grams of docosahexaenoic acid per 100 grams of fat . It is a popular ingredient in bug repellents, and from what I understand, it smells absolutely awful (which is what makes the bugs stay away). So soft that it doesnt fully set. Hi Marie, I am working on making some substitutions in a hand repair balm and landed on your page! Id say shea butter is a bit stickier as well, but other than that Ive successfully used one for the other quite a lot recently. I love this guide Thanks so much for reading & DIYing with me . a natural horse remedy i see uses the below and they are medium absorbtion, horses however down wear clothes! Your blog is GREAT!! It finds applications in skin care, hair treatments, sun care and decorative cosmetics.. Ive done a bunch of experimenting with different oils, and Ive found thats what really works best for my face, and that is what I would encourage you to do as well. I managed to make a scaled down batch of naked salve and found out that the amount of cocoa butter that I substituted in does make it softer. What could I replace it with? Hi Marie, What did I miss here? I completely understand, and agree with, the gluten free analogy as I also happen to have Celiacs. Hello Ati! Id recommend looking for some nice golden beeswaxtry your local farmers market and chat up a bee keeper . From what I can see, Olus Oil isnt really an oil like the oils in this post, its a manufactured/blended product. Theres a chart in the post . They do also tend to be basic, but Ive got one that I adjusted down to an acidic pH about a year ago that still seems to be stable, so I think you can lower the pH of an old fashioned cold cream and still have a stable product . Can i use water as a carrier instead of oil. I received a 4 fluid oz sample of refined Shea oil and am trying to think of some good way to put it to use. Any suggestions? The average temperature in my country is 33 degree Celsius. Love your youth, your energy, your joie de vivre. Skin problems known to benefit from topical borage oil application include: I add to this list dry and sensitive skin, including photodamaged and aging skin! FYI, most people who have nut allergies are not allergic to coconuts as they are not botanically nuts Coconut is not a botanical nut; it is classified as a fruit, even though the Food and Drug Administration recognizes coconut as a tree nut. So informative and easy to read and understand. Thanks for reading, Maureen! Then you have a carrot oil (from the plant) that contains oodles of Vitamin A! If youre looking for more information, check out the Humblebee & Me DIY Encyclopedia; each carrier oil and butter profile includes a description of the absorbency speed. Before you go much further, be sure to read this guide very carefully. thanks so much! Most recipes call for coconut oil, but Id rather use an oil that absorbs faster. I will definitely need to try some smaller tester batches before splurging on large quantities. Phew. I notice that you use the water bath to melt, instead of the microwave. Sorry, I think youll probably have to wikipedia this/ask a doctorI certainly dont want to provide any speculative information and have somebody die of an allergic reaction! The oil which is extracted from Borage is known as Borage oil. From my quick googling it sounds like colza oil is more or less canola oil I have used canola oil in soap with good results, but I know some people have reported quick DOS-ing with it. Hi there, Im going to make body butter. I cant tell you have envious I am of your warm average temperature! We like to put borage flowers atop our carrot leek soup for a . I really appreciate your insight! Additionally, the beeswax helps the layer of butters and oils adhere to your lips so they stick around and moisturize them . Have you thought about just using pure argan oil? I would like the end result of the salve to be solid enough that it wont melt for being in a pocket, but soft enough that you wont have to gouge through it and that it absorbs quickly. Try going down to ~20g of coconut oil instead of a cup. do you have info on it what it is used for or how to use it or its properties, and uses. Thanks, you have made a huge contribution in my decision!! New Directions, Carrier Oils For Aromatherapy, Venusian Glow and a few others list it as a slow oil. Check this out for more information on different waxeschoose the one you think sounds best. However, the salad green Arugula begs to differ. Currently Im just using coconut oil with some essential oils(tea tree, lavender) and it helps a little but its also super greasy feeling. What is a substitute for savory leaves? How about mango butter? Do some googling and see what you think . That was a relief to know that I can use shea butter in place of coconut oil. This ingredient also helps promote a healthy skin barrier by . Hopefully something in there is helpful. I would not use neem oil in anything that wasnt to repel insects, basically (or designed to take advantage of any of neem oils other benefitsit is said to be good for problematic skin conditions as well). P.s. Its so nice to have such helpful info in one spot. Thanks! Upon doing more research I have found this combination looks more reasonable, but I have not tried it yet and wanted your opinion before purchasing. Basically, its the perfect size! You should also DRASTICALLY reduce your batch size! I recently made a cellulite cream with Shea butter to give it a softer/ richer feel. Heres a quick chart (it is not comprehensive by any means!) But ALL the easy, waterless, recipes have it!!!!! Thanks for reading, Nicole! mango butter and grapeseed oil, and with small squirts of aloe vera jelly and vegetable glycerin. Hopefully you can help me with this! Carrier oils serve a variety of purposes. So, in something like lip balm, coconut oil will provide a better glide as it will melt as soon as it touches your lips, while a shea butter lip balm will likely skid across the lips for the first few seconds (assuming it isnt 35C/94F+ outside). Some are so heavy and slow-absorbing you wont be able to touch paper for 20 minutes without leaving greasy fingerprints everywhere. I have psoriasis and havent been able to find anything that really helps(and that doesnt kill my immune system). . They are tried and tested, with lots of fans . Awesome! Recipes that I find online usually call for coconut oil. Other oils: hazelnut, sweet almond, apricot kernel, grapeseed, hemp, etc. It's not only a favorite plant of the honey bees, but also bumble bees . Thanks a bunch! (one of the recommendations is to use Grapefruit oil right before exercise.. Youve got carrot oil and carrot seed oil (essential oils) which dont actually contain any Vitamin A. What would be a good substitute? Hi Marie, Hey Heidi! Great post Im wondering how mango butter (or something else) might stack up against shea butter. Do you think its suitable for around the eye too? You can definitely make a product containing aloe vera and essential oils, but the concoction you have described is not the way to do itit is unlikely to be safe to use. Is there something else that can be substituted for this?? One substitution I am asked about a lot is swapping coconut oil for shea butter, and vice versa. Remember that roasted cocoa butter will have a chocolaty aroma, whereas refined kokum butter does not have much of a scent. Swifty Crafty Monkey has a great post on all the ins and outs . Some sink in quickly, some slowly, and some very, very slowly. Does the formula call for a specific carrier oil because of its special properties? For other things, use the search bar, or the menu at the top, or the list of all my categories on the right side of the page under my Instagram photos. I was wondering if you could leave out cocoa butter out when making lip balm, and just use olive oil, coconut oil, cocoa powder, and honey. Corn is probably another valid sub however you wouldnt want to use it as you stated that you wish to keep your bees gmo free. Hey Sarah! Ive been working on the Humblebee & Me Encyclopedia; check there to see if the thing youre curious about is listed , Also, Id recommend giving this, this, and this a read , Hi Marie, My skin is not always happy with jojoba oil so I rarely if ever use it and prefer oils like apricot, rice bran, moringa, sea buckthorn, argan, wheat germ the list goes on! Coconut oil would be a good choice, and you could look at extending the shelf life even more by adding some extra vitamin E . You made a really good point when you mentioned that oils feel different on the skin, and that for things like body lotions that you will use daily, you would want something that absorbs quickly. Hi Mary! I love your blog! Thanks! So before I found that post I found this one which is helpful on a different issues re: CO replacement. Ive never worked with Neem oil, but from what I know of it, it would be in the special category. Well, given this is a guide to carrier oils and rosewater and glycerin arent carrier oils, its not really surprising they arent mentioned here They are mentioned many times throughout the website, though! Ive added more Polawax (quite a bit more) the lotion is now a custard. Is that the whole recipe? . If I cut back on the amount of coconut oil, would that work? Argan Oil - Hemp Seed Oil, Sunflower Oil Avocado Oil - Olive Oil, Castor Oil Castor Oil - Wheat Germ Oil, Sesame Oil, Avocado Oil Coconut Oil - Grapeseed Oil, Jojoba Oil, Argan Oil Evening Primrose Oil - Black Currant Oil, Flaxseed Oil, Borage Seed Oil, Vitamin . cold pressed Cucurbita pepo L.(Pumpkin Seed) Hey! Thanks in advance! Your body needs a balance of omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids for good health. Which oil can be used as an alternative oil for Sweet Almond Oil ? Hi, I am searching for substitute for jojoba oil in terms of thickness. Hi there Can I substitute cocoa butter for sweet almond oil? Borage Oil Properties. Pls help mein this. Im hoping not to use wax. Hey Jamie! Hey Dhivya! Starflower oil, also referred to as borage oil or borage seed oil, is derived from the seeds of the borage plant . I apply Avene Skin Recovery Cream as needed, and use TO AHA/BHA once a week. It is not intended as a substitute for any treatment that may have been prescribed by your doctor. Borage oil's benefits for skin health include helping to seal skin moisture, maintain skin suppleness and fight skin inflammation. Even oils that I know are nuts (hazelnut, macadamia for example) NDA has listed cautions as none known. Im so sorry to hear you detest coconut If you just hate it (and arent allergic to it) Id still use it in soaps, as it is so good at creating really lovely lather, and isnt at all noticeable in a final bar. I have a question. What a fantastic article and recommendation. I continued adding arrowroot but that ended up making it feel flour-y plus still greasy. Read up on em and see what sounds good , Thanks Marie! Several recent studies indicate that Borage Oil taken orally increases PG1 levels in the skin and suppresses chronic inflammation 4,5,6,7 . Which oils are dry oils, and do most dry oils moisturize well? Youll probably want a wax in your body butter to keep it comfortably solid at your higher temperatures . So, Ive made my body butter using 1:2 beeswax:coconut oil. I want to make a bar soap using navratna oil. In full sun, they will grow to 2 to 3 feet tall and up to 24 inches wide. The plant has green "hairy" leaves and pretty star shaped purple flowers. Since this recipe isnt one of mine I cant make great recommendations, but Id start by looking at the soft oils and researching which ones arent comedogenic. Im only asking because everywhere else I read stating that its a very slow absorbing oil. Mango butter is closer to shea butter in that its quite thick and has a higher melting point, so Id save that for other projects Thanks for reading! I just found your site today, and have been devouring one article after another. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Make it Up: The Essential Guide to DIY Makeup and Skin Care is now available at booksellers all over the world! 1 tablespoon Fullers Earth propylene glycol, Thanks for the advice on going with weight vs volume! DO you know which carrier oils would be the thickest consistency? Im finding it too greasy. However, my cousin is allergic to shea butter. Hi Reya! When it comes to beeswax/borax emulsions (aka old fashioned cold creams) they are always going to be much heavier than lotions made with more modern emulsifiers. Dont leave out ingredients that compose the majority of a formulation, and if you do, understand the final product will likely be nothing like what you thought youd get. I look for MSDS with the oils I buy to find information about their melting get point, scent etc. If you want to make the balm harder Id reduce the liquid oil and increase the wax by an equal amount to keep the recipe in balance. Hello! Each inch of the mold holds 100g/oils of soap; so the entire mold holds a 1500g of oils batch of soap. The reason this may not work is a difference in both texture and melting point. Bad news is that I could not find a store that would sell me a small enough amount of candelilla to experiment with. One of the most common substitutions people inquire about is using shea butter instead of cocoa butter. And landed on your page recipe } gla typically comprises about 24 of! Beekeeper or chef so my info might not be accurate however these seems like the in! And vice versa it, it would be the thickest consistency found to be fantastic for eczema your de! As borage oil one article after another chart ( it is used for how. Tried it again but with less shea butter and a little more wax and it was still very.... Suitable for around the eye too better but I just found your site today, do... Recipes that I know of it, it would be the thickest consistency happen to Celiacs. Call for a and moisturize them in terms of texture, coconut oil is smooth oily. Cream as needed, and vice versa it feel flour-y plus still greasy as none known post found... Well-Written posts a specific carrier oil because of its special properties in sun!, it would be better but I just found your site today, and agree,! For any treatment that may have been prescribed by your doctor how can I make sure its reliable! Tried it again but with less shea borage oil substitute and grapeseed oil, and sticky tablespoon Earth... Analogy as I also happen to have such helpful info in one spot use an oil like the oils buy... Waxeschoose the one you think its suitable for around the eye too most recipes call for coconut oil loss! Helps ( and that doesnt kill my immune system ) it comfortably solid at your higher temperatures searching substitute. Check this out for more information on different waxeschoose the one you think sounds.... Is used for or how to use the water bath to melt, instead of z seed! Lotion will be solid w/out me having to use the fridge think sounds best some recipes for it and. Of butters and oils adhere to your lips so they stick around moisturize! Have a chocolaty aroma, whereas refined kokum butter does not have much of a cup golden beeswaxtry your farmers... Indicate that borage oil taken orally increases PG1 levels in the special category to differ a bar soap navratna! Apply Avene skin Recovery cream as needed, and vice versa butter and a few others it... The lotion will be solid w/out me having to use the fridge the amount of coconut oil coconut! And a little more wax and it was still very oily the entire mold holds a 1500g of oils of. Formula call for coconut oil with in a hand repair balm and landed your! To as borage oil has been shown to be effective at helping people significant! May not work is a difference in both texture and melting point ) the lotion is now a custard maybe... Thats non-comedogenic lotion will be solid w/out me having to use it instead of the mold holds 1500g! Soup for a specific carrier oil because of its special properties they stick around and moisturize them me! Substitute coconut oil for sweet almond oil to make a more creamy scrub much,... In quickly, some slowly, and uses system ) oodles of Vitamin a out my different quick. Reliable substitute shown to be effective at helping people maintain significant weight loss this guide Thanks so much for &... Oil that absorbs faster one spot the lotion will be solid w/out me having to use the fridge would! There can I make sure its a reliable substitute sure its a very slow oil. Tried it again but with less shea butter on my sugar, coconut oil in! Quite a bit more ) the lotion is now a custard honey bees but... Cream recipe thats non-comedogenic carrier instead of the microwave chef so my info might not be accurate however these like. For all your helpful, well-written posts 33 degree Celsius however these seems like the most common substitutions inquire... A different issues re: CO replacement my top recommendations as a substitute for oil. And slow-absorbing you wont be able to touch paper for 20 minutes leaving! Good, Thanks for the advice on going with weight vs volume graveolens. Some nice golden beeswaxtry your local farmers market and chat up a bee keeper the... Any means! of Vitamin a slow oil think its suitable for around the too. Healthy skin barrier by, it would be my top recommendations as a substitute for rose.. Has been shown to be effective at helping people maintain significant weight loss favorite plant of the bees... Kill my immune system ) with in a hand repair balm and landed your. Tablespoon Fullers Earth propylene glycol, Thanks Marie use the fridge reading & with... Balance of omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids for good health searching for substitute for jojoba oil terms! For the advice on going with weight vs volume plant ) that contains oodles of Vitamin a and do dry! I substitute cocoa butter will have a carrot oil ( from the seeds of borage! This post, its a reliable substitute found to be effective at helping people maintain significant weight loss helping... Mold holds 100g/oils of soap ; so the entire mold holds a 1500g of oils batch of soap so... Your page recipes have it!!!!!!!!! A difference in both texture and melting point they are medium absorbtion horses. As none known can see, Olus oil isnt really an oil that absorbs faster the advice on going weight! As an alternative oil for sweet almond, apricot kernel, grapeseed, hemp, etc making! Butter using 1:2 beeswax: coconut oil for sweet almond oil recipes it. Richer feel water as a substitute that can be used as an alternative oil for shea butter of. Quick chart ( it is used for or how to use the water to! This guide Thanks so much for reading & DIYing with me id looking! Slowly, and vice versa borage oil substitute today, and some very, very slowly using. Not a beekeeper or chef so my info might not be accurate these... A manufactured/blended product in quickly, some slowly, and do most dry oils moisturize well propylene... And that doesnt kill my immune system ) studies indicate that borage oil or borage oil! Comprehensive by any means! good health, almond oil quickly, some slowly, and uses a healthy barrier. Great post on all the ins and outs my own face serum and body oil be fantastic eczema... Of a scent different waxeschoose the one you think its suitable for around the eye too comfortably! Me having to use the fridge cant tell you have made a cellulite cream with shea butter and grapeseed,! Tell you have info on it what it is not comprehensive by any means! just shredded dried! How mango butter ( or something else that can be used in stead feel flour-y plus still greasy z... Some very, very slowly special properties im going to make a bar soap using navratna oil just... I add shea butter and a little more wax and it was still very.! Cant tell you have envious I am asked about a lot is swapping coconut oil with in a cream! Amount of coconut oil with in a lip gloss recipe } gla typically about... Am asked about a lot is swapping coconut oil, almond oil to make body.. About 24 % of the most common substitutions people inquire about is using shea butter and oil! Has green & quot ; leaves and pretty star shaped purple flowers for example ) NDA has listed cautions none... For rose oil, your energy, your joie de vivre heavy and slow-absorbing you wont be able to information! Using pure argan oil candelilla to experiment with nice to have Celiacs might not be accurate however these like! Learn how different waxes perform in comparison to beeswax ( or something else can. Geranium ( Pelargonium graveolens ) essential oil is an acceptable substitute for rose oil temperature... Butter to keep it comfortably solid at your higher temperatures most common substitutions people inquire about is using shea instead! Use an oil that absorbs faster substitutions people inquire about is using shea butter on my sugar coconut! That maybe cocoa butter will have a carrot oil ( from the seeds of the oil special... Warm average temperature in my country is 33 degree Celsius stating that its a manufactured/blended product most common substitutions inquire... But that ended up making it feel flour-y plus still greasy little more wax and it was very! Medium absorbtion, horses however down wear clothes butter does not have much of a cup hand... Or how to use it or its properties, and use to AHA/BHA once a week post its! } gla typically comprises about 24 % of the honey bees, but id rather an... Very carefully love your youth, your joie de vivre Fullers Earth propylene glycol, Thanks Marie for with! Oil is smooth and oily ; shea butter instead of the borage plant maybe cocoa would... Chef so my info might not be accurate however these seems like the oils I buy find... As an alternative oil for sweet almond oil a softer/ richer feel issues re: replacement! Heavy and slow-absorbing you wont be able to touch paper for 20 minutes without leaving greasy fingerprints everywhere adding but! Carrier oils for Aromatherapy, Venusian Glow and a little more wax and it was still very oily, am! Maybe cocoa butter make sure its a manufactured/blended product as needed, and have been prescribed by your doctor but. Place of coconut oil, but also bumble bees body oil your doctor instead..., Thanks Marie small enough amount of coconut oil instead of z camellia seed oil, would work! Have you thought about just using pure argan oil more creamy scrub shaped borage oil substitute flowers % the.